English Setter vs Irish Setter

Compare English Setters to Irish Setters. Use the tool below to compare temperament, size, personality, maintenance requirements, and everything else between these two breeds.

English Setter vs Irish Setter
English Setter
Irish Setter
English Setter
Irish Setter
Change Breed
Change Breed
General Details
English Setter
Irish Setter
Breed Type
Purebred
Purebred
Allergy Friendly
No
No
Lifespan
10-12 Years
11-15 Years
Height
23-27 Inches
25-27 Inches
Weight
45-80 Pounds
60-70 Pounds
Intelligence
Above Average
Above Average
History
English Setter
Irish Setter
Origin Country
United Kingdom
Ireland
Origin Year
1825 AD
1780 AD
Temperament
English Setter
Irish Setter
Overall Friendliness
Above Average
Above Average
Family Friendly
Above Average
Above Average
Child Friendly
Above Average
Above Average
Pet Friendly
Above Average
Above Average
Stranger Friendly
Above Average
Above Average
Personality
English Setter
Irish Setter
Traits
Affectionate
Needy
Separation Anxiety
Stubborn
Willing to Please
Affectionate
Loving
Separation Anxiety
Willing to Please
Living Environment
English Setter
Irish Setter
Apartment
No
No
Indoor
No
Yes
Small Yard
No
No
Medium Yard
Yes
Yes
Large Yard
Yes
Yes
Temperature Tolerance
45-80 °F
50-80 °F
Barks/Howls
Above Average
Average
Exercise Needs
English Setter
Irish Setter
Energy Level
High
Very High
Exercise Required
High to Very High
Very High
Top Running Speed
21 MPH
28 MPH
Strength
Medium
High
Grooming Needs
English Setter
Irish Setter
Coat Maintenance
Medium
Medium
Shedding
Medium
Medium
Dander
Low
Medium
Drool
Low
Medium
Instincts and Behavior
Breed Mentality
English Setter
Irish Setter
Dominant / Alpha
No
No
Family / Pack
Yes
Yes
Independent
Yes
No
Breed Focus
English Setter
Irish Setter
Distracted Easy
Yes
No
Focused & Patient
No
No
Breed Instincts
English Setter
Irish Setter
Aggression
Below Average
None
Burrow / Digging
Below Average
Below Average
Chasing
Average
Average
Follow Commands
Below Average
Below Average
Fighting
Below Average
Below Average
Guarding
Below Average
Below Average
Herding
Below Average
Below Average
Hunting
Above Average
Above Average
Protection
Below Average
Below Average
Remove Vermin
Above Average
Below Average
Sled Pulling
None
None
Watch / Guardian
Below Average
Above Average
Health Comparison
Lifespan
English Setter
Irish Setter
Average Lifespan
10-12 Years
11-15 Years
Health Concerns
English Setter
Irish Setter
Common Health Issues
Cancer
Hip dysplasia
Von willebrand's disease
Progressive retinal atrophy
Allergies
Hypothyroidism
Elbow dysplasia
Osteochondritis Dissecans
Heart problems
Eye diseases
Hemophilia A
Lysosomal storage diseases
Bloat
Cancer
Hip dysplasia
Progressive retinal atrophy
Epilepsy
Hypothyroidism
Osteochondritis Dissecans
Panosteitis
Canine leukocyte adhesion deficiency
Hypertrophic osteodystrophy
Appearance Comparison
Coat
English Setter
Irish Setter
Coat Type
Fur
Hair
Coat Layering
Smooth
Single
Smooth
Coat Texture
Silky
Silky
Straight
Coat Length
Medium to Long
Long
Coat Coloring
English Setter
Irish Setter
Breed Colors
Menu