Saint Bernard vs Scotch Collie
Compare the Saint Bernard to the Scotch Collie. Use the tool below to compare temperament, size, personality, maintenance requirements, and everything else between Saint Bernards and Scotch Collies.
Scotch Collie
Saint Bernard
Breed Type
Purebred
Purebred
Allergy Friendly
No
No
Lifespan
12-16 Years
8-10 Years
Height
19-24 Inches
25½-27½ Inches
Weight
40-70 Pounds
110-200 Pounds
Intelligence
Scotch Collie
Saint Bernard
Origin Country
Unspecified
Switzerland
Origin Year
1600 AD
1695 AD
Scotch Collie
Saint Bernard
Overall Friendliness
Family Friendly
Child Friendly
Pet Friendly
Stranger Friendly
Scotch Collie
Saint Bernard
Scotch Collie
Saint Bernard
Apartment
Yes
Yes
Indoor
Yes
Yes
Small Yard
Yes
Yes
Medium Yard
Yes
Yes
Large Yard
Yes
Yes
Temperature Tolerance
25-80 °F
20-85 °F
Barks/Howls
Scotch Collie
Saint Bernard
Energy Level
High
Low
Exercise Required
High
Low to Medium
Top Running Speed
28 MPH
20 MPH
Strength
Medium
Very High
Scotch Collie
Saint Bernard
Coat Maintenance
Medium
Medium
Shedding
Low to Medium
Medium
Dander
Low to Medium
Medium
Drool
None
High
Scotch Collie
Saint Bernard
Dominant / Alpha
No
No
Family / Pack
Yes
Yes
Independent
No
No
Scotch Collie
Saint Bernard
Distracted Easy
No
No
Focused & Patient
Yes
No
Scotch Collie
Saint Bernard
Aggression
Burrow / Digging
Chasing
Follow Commands
Fighting
Guarding
Herding
Hunting
Protection
Remove Vermin
Sled Pulling
Watch / Guardian
Scotch Collie
Saint Bernard
Average Lifespan
12-16 Years
8-10 Years
Scotch Collie
Saint Bernard
Scotch Collie
Saint Bernard
Coat Type
Fur
Fur
Coat Layering
Double
Double
Coat Texture
Straight
Rough
Straight
Coat Length
Medium
Medium
Scotch Collie
Saint Bernard
